What should you push back on when a large customer sends its master services agreement? Start with the four terms that move real money: indemnity, limitation of liability, insurance requirements and renewal or termination rights. A big customer’s MSA is written to protect the big customer, and it usually shifts open-ended risk onto the vendor in ways the vendor’s insurance won’t cover. Most of those terms are negotiable, even with very large companies, if you ask early, ask specifically and offer reasonable alternatives. The goal isn’t to win every clause. It’s to make sure one bad project can’t take down your company.

I’ve advised founders and owners for more than 20 years, and I see this most often right after a growing company lands its first marquee customer. The deal feels like a win, the MSA arrives with a request to sign by Friday, and nobody wants to be the person who slows things down. That’s exactly when the expensive mistakes get made. Here’s how I’d read the document.

Why is the indemnity clause the first thing to read?

Because it decides who pays when something goes wrong, and customer forms almost always make that you. A typical customer indemnity requires the vendor to defend and indemnify the customer, its affiliates, officers and employees against “any and all claims arising out of or relating to” the services. That language can sweep in claims caused partly or even mostly by the customer. It also usually includes a duty to defend, which means you may pay the customer’s lawyers from day one, before anyone decides who was at fault.

Push to narrow it. Indemnity should be tied to third-party claims, not every dispute between the two of you. It should be limited to claims caused by your negligence, willful misconduct or breach, and reduced to the extent the customer contributed. Ask for the customer to indemnify you too, at least for claims arising from its own materials, data, instructions and negligence. Make sure you get prompt notice of a claim and the right to control the defense, so you aren’t paying for counsel you didn’t pick. And don’t assume a broad clause will be thrown out. Negotiate as if every word will be enforced.

What does a limitation of liability actually protect?

A good limitation of liability puts a ceiling on what you can owe and excludes categories of damages that can dwarf the contract value. The common structure caps each party’s total liability at the fees paid or payable over a set period, often 12 months, and excludes consequential, incidental and lost-profit damages for both sides. Many customer forms either leave this clause out, make it one-sided in the customer’s favor, or bury exceptions that swallow the cap.

Read the carve-outs carefully. Customers will ask to exclude indemnity, confidentiality and data breaches from the cap. Some of that is reasonable. But if indemnity is uncapped and indemnity is broad, your cap is close to meaningless. A practical middle ground is a separate, higher “super cap” for data and confidentiality claims, often a multiple of annual fees or tied to the cyber coverage you actually carry. Fraud and willful misconduct are usually fair carve-outs. “Any breach of Section 9” usually isn’t.

Make the cap mutual. If the customer can walk away from paying your invoices and owe only limited damages, you should get the same protection on the other side.

How should you handle the insurance requirements?

Send the insurance exhibit to your broker before you sign, not after. Customer forms often require limits you don’t carry, coverage lines you don’t have, and endorsements that cost money or take time: additional insured status, waiver of subrogation, primary and noncontributory wording, and 30 days’ notice of cancellation. Some require professional liability or cyber coverage at levels that make sense for a national bank and not for a 30-person firm.

Your broker can tell you what you have, what you can add and what it costs. Then negotiate to match reality. Ask to satisfy higher limits with an umbrella policy. Ask for limits proportionate to the contract value. If an endorsement isn’t available on your policy, say so and propose an alternative. What you don’t want is to sign a contract you’re already in breach of on day one, because that hands the customer an easy argument the first time there’s friction.

Also understand how insurance and indemnity interact. Most commercial general liability policies cover some contractual indemnity obligations, but not all of them, and professional errors are usually outside that coverage. If you promise more than your policies cover, the gap is paid from your balance sheet.

Which renewal, termination and payment terms deserve attention?

Auto-renewal clauses cut both ways. They can lock you into pricing that no longer works, with a narrow window to give notice of non-renewal. Calendar every notice date the day you sign. Ask for a price adjustment mechanism at each renewal, and look for a clause that lets the customer terminate for convenience on short notice while you’re bound for the full term. If they can leave, you should be able to leave, or at least get paid for work in progress and committed costs.

Payment terms matter just as much. Large customers commonly push net 60 or net 90 terms, and some forms let them withhold payment for any dispute or set off amounts from other contracts. Negotiate to limit withholding to the disputed portion, pay the rest on time, and require disputes to be raised in writing within a set number of days. Check the governing law and venue too. Litigating in the customer’s home state is a real cost, so know what you’re agreeing to.

How do you push back without losing the deal?

Lead with a short issues list, not a full redline of every clause. Procurement teams deal with vendor pushback every day, and they respond better to five focused, well-reasoned asks than to forty edits. Explain each ask in business terms: “Our insurance covers X, so we need the cap to match,” is easier to approve than “This is one-sided.”

Know your walk-away points before you start. For most of my clients those are an uncapped indemnity for anything other than narrow categories, insurance requirements they can’t meet, and payment terms that would strain cash flow. Everything else is a trade. And check the order of precedence clause, so the statement of work you negotiate for each project actually controls over the MSA where the two conflict.

Frequently asked questions

Will a large company really negotiate its MSA?

Often, yes. Most large companies have pre-approved fallback positions on liability caps, insurance and payment terms that their contracts team can agree to without escalation. You won’t get those positions unless you ask for them.

Is a mutual indemnity always better for the vendor?

Not automatically. A mutual clause is only as good as its scope, and a mutual clause that’s broad on your side and narrow on theirs is still one-sided. Read both directions separately.

What if I already signed an MSA with bad terms?

Look at the renewal date, because that’s your natural point to renegotiate. Meanwhile, use each new statement of work to clarify scope and, where the order of precedence allows it, adjust risk on that project. Your insurance broker should also review what you’ve already agreed to.

Talk with Scott

A big customer can make your year. The wrong MSA can make it your last. If you’re looking at a customer contract and aren’t sure what to push back on, I’m glad to talk it through. Reach me at slevine@aegislaw.com.

By Scott Levine, Founder and Managing Partner, AEGIS Law

Attorney Advertising. This article is general information published by AEGIS Law for marketing purposes. It is not legal advice and should not be relied on as legal advice. It may not reflect current law, may not apply in your state or to your facts, and may contain errors or omissions. Laws change often and vary from state to state. Before acting on anything you read here, talk with a lawyer licensed in your jurisdiction who has reviewed your situation. Reading this article or contacting AEGIS Law does not create an attorney-client relationship, and you should not send confidential information until one exists. AEGIS Law lawyers are licensed in various states, and no lawyer is licensed in every state. Unless stated otherwise, no AEGIS Law lawyer is certified as a specialist by any state board or certifying organization. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Lawyer responsible for this content: Scott Levine, AEGIS Law, 601 S. Lindbergh Blvd., Frontenac, Missouri 63131, (314) 454-9100. The choice of a lawyer is an important decision and should not be based solely upon advertisements.

Select Categories

Strategic Engagement

Consult with our Managing Partner.

Ready to review your enterprise risk or legacy strategy? Schedule a direct consultation with Scott Levine using the link below.

Schedule an Appointment

BOOK NOW


Call Us

(314) 454-9100