What do you risk when a court freezes someone else’s assets? You risk the injunction bond. Before a federal court issues a temporary restraining order or preliminary injunction, Rule 65(c) generally requires the party asking for it to post security in an amount the court considers proper to pay the costs and damages of anyone later found to have been wrongfully enjoined. If you win the injunction but lose the case, the other side can recover its provable losses from that bond. In most courts, the bond also acts as a ceiling on what they can recover, absent bad faith or a separate claim. So the bond is both your exposure and your protection, and it belongs in your budget from the first day.

I’m writing this because owners who seek emergency relief are usually focused on the threat in front of them: diverted funds, stolen customers or a business partner moving assets. That’s the right focus. But I’ve seen the bond treated as an afterthought, and the cost and risk it carries deserve a decision of their own.

What does Rule 65(c) require?

The text is short. The court may issue a preliminary injunction or temporary restraining order only if the movant gives security in an amount the court considers proper. The United States and its agencies are exempt. Most states have similar rules, and Missouri’s rules generally require a bond before a restraining order or preliminary injunction issues as well.

The purpose is fairness. An injunction is entered before the facts are fully tested. If it later turns out the restrained party was entitled to do what it was stopped from doing, the bond is the fund that compensates it. That’s why courts take the requirement seriously even when the movant’s case looks strong.

A related point surprises many owners. Federal courts generally can’t freeze a defendant’s assets before judgment just to secure a future money judgment. Asset freezes are usually tied to equitable claims, such as a claim to specific funds, a constructive trust or certain statutory remedies. Whether an asset freeze is available at all is often the first legal fight.

How do courts set the amount?

Courts have broad discretion. The usual starting point is a realistic estimate of the harm the enjoined party could suffer if the injunction turns out to be wrong: lost profits, lost business opportunities, carrying costs on frozen assets, interest and the cost of complying. The restrained party typically offers evidence of that harm, and the movant argues for a lower figure.

Some courts have approved nominal or even no bond in particular circumstances, such as when the risk of harm is remote or the movant has limited means and a strong public interest claim. Don’t count on that. In commercial cases, especially where operating funds or accounts are frozen, the bond can be substantial.

Come prepared with your own evidence on the amount. If the injunction is narrow, explain why the harm will be small. If the defendant has other assets or can operate around the restriction, say so. A well supported request for a reasonable bond is far more persuasive than a general plea for a low one.

When can the restrained party recover on the bond?

Generally, when the party has been “wrongfully enjoined,” meaning it’s ultimately determined that it had the right to do what the injunction prohibited. That determination usually comes at the end of the case, not when the injunction is dissolved for a technical reason. Some federal courts apply a presumption in favor of recovery once that showing is made, while others treat recovery as discretionary.

Recovery is limited to damages actually caused by the injunction, and those damages must be proven. In most courts, the bond amount is also the maximum recovery against the bond, which gives the movant a measure of certainty. That cap generally doesn’t protect against separate claims, such as malicious prosecution or abuse of process, if the injunction was sought in bad faith.

Under Rule 65.1, a surety that posts the bond submits to the court’s jurisdiction, and its liability can be enforced by motion in the same case without a separate lawsuit. That makes bond claims relatively quick to pursue.

How do sureties, renewals and releases work?

Most movants post the bond through a commercial surety rather than cash. The surety charges an annual premium, usually a percentage of the bond amount, and often requires collateral and a written indemnity agreement. Expect the surety to ask the company’s owners to sign personally. Read that agreement carefully, because if the surety pays a claim, it will look to you to be repaid.

Bonds aren’t static. As a case goes on, the restrained party may ask the court to increase the bond because its losses have grown. The movant may ask to reduce it if the injunction is narrowed. Premiums renew annually, so a case that runs for years carries a recurring cost.

When the case ends, the bond isn’t automatically released. If the movant wins, it typically asks the court to exonerate the bond and discharge the surety. If the movant loses, the restrained party usually has a set time to file a claim. Close the loop with a court order so the surety releases collateral and stops billing premiums.

Why should a plaintiff budget for the bond?

Because it’s often the difference between getting relief and not. A court may grant the motion and condition the injunction on a bond the movant can’t promptly post. Courts may also allow only a short time to post it. Owners who haven’t lined up a surety in advance can lose days they don’t have.

The budget isn’t only the premium. It includes collateral tied up for the life of the case and the contingent liability if the injunction is later found wrongful. Before filing, ask your lawyer for a realistic bond range, line up a surety and decide whether the relief justifies the exposure. Sometimes a narrower order, with a smaller bond, is the better business decision.

Frequently asked questions

Can a court waive the bond entirely?

Some courts have set a nominal bond or none in unusual circumstances. In commercial disputes, that’s uncommon, and you should plan for a real number.

Is the bond refunded if I win?

The bond itself is released, and collateral is returned, once the court exonerates it. Premiums paid to the surety are generally not refunded, though they may be recoverable as costs in some courts.

Can the defendant recover more than the bond amount?

In most courts, not on the bond itself. A separate claim, such as one based on bad faith, may allow more, but those claims are harder to prove.

Talk with Scott

If you’re considering emergency relief, or you’ve been restrained by one, the bond deserves careful attention. I’m glad to help you weigh the cost and the risk. Reach me at slevine@aegislaw.com.

By Scott Levine, Founder and Managing Partner, AEGIS Law

Attorney Advertising. This article is general information published by AEGIS Law for marketing purposes. It is not legal advice and should not be relied on as legal advice. It may not reflect current law, may not apply in your state or to your facts, and may contain errors or omissions. Laws change often and vary from state to state. Before acting on anything you read here, talk with a lawyer licensed in your jurisdiction who has reviewed your situation. Reading this article or contacting AEGIS Law does not create an attorney-client relationship, and you should not send confidential information until one exists. AEGIS Law lawyers are licensed in various states, and no lawyer is licensed in every state. Unless stated otherwise, no AEGIS Law lawyer is certified as a specialist by any state board or certifying organization. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Lawyer responsible for this content: Scott Levine, AEGIS Law, 601 S. Lindbergh Blvd., Frontenac, Missouri 63131, (314) 454-9100. The choice of a lawyer is an important decision and should not be based solely upon advertisements.

Select Categories

Strategic Engagement

Consult with our Managing Partner.

Ready to review your enterprise risk or legacy strategy? Schedule a direct consultation with Scott Levine using the link below.

Schedule an Appointment

BOOK NOW


Call Us

(314) 454-9100