How do you let someone go without inviting a lawsuit? Make the decision for documented, legitimate business reasons, apply your policies consistently and handle the conversation with respect. If you offer severance, tie it to a written separation agreement with a release that meets the legal requirements in your state and under federal law, especially for employees 40 and older. Review any noncompete or nonsolicitation agreement before you rely on it, because the rules differ sharply from state to state. And if a former employee files an agency charge, respond carefully, on time and with counsel, because your first response often shapes the rest of the case.
I’ve counseled founders and owners through terminations for more than 20 years. I see the most risk when a small company handles its first difficult termination the way it handled hiring: informally, quickly and on instinct. Most terminations don’t lead to claims. The ones that do usually started with a rushed decision, a missing paper trail or a release that didn’t hold up.
What should happen before the termination meeting?
Most employment in Missouri, Illinois and most other states is at will, which means you can generally end it for any lawful reason or no reason. But at will doesn’t mean risk free. You can’t terminate someone for a discriminatory reason, in retaliation for a complaint, for taking protected leave or for reporting a safety or legal concern. In a lawsuit, the question becomes whether your stated reason is the real one.
So before the meeting, look at the file. Is the reason documented in reviews, warnings or emails? Have others who did the same thing been treated the same way? Did the employee recently complain, request leave or disclose a medical condition? If the timing looks bad, slow down and get advice. Also confirm your state’s final paycheck rules. Some states require final wages almost immediately, and the deadlines and penalties vary.
What makes a severance agreement and release hold up?
Severance is generally not required by law. It’s a payment in exchange for something, most often a release of claims. For the release to hold up, the employee has to receive something they weren’t already entitled to, like extra pay or benefits beyond earned wages and accrued benefits your policies already owe. The agreement should be clear, signed voluntarily and specific about what’s released.
For employees 40 and older, the federal Older Workers Benefit Protection Act adds strict requirements to release age discrimination claims. The agreement generally must be written in plain language, specifically mention the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, advise the employee in writing to consult a lawyer, give at least 21 days to consider it, and allow seven days to revoke after signing. In a group termination program, the review period is generally 45 days, and you must provide information about who was selected and who wasn’t. Miss a step, and the age claim release may not be enforceable.
Some claims can’t be released by private agreement, or can be released only with court or agency approval. These generally include unemployment benefits, certain wage claims under the Fair Labor Standards Act and the right to file a charge with a government agency. You can usually require the employee to waive any money recovery from a charge, but not the right to file one. Illinois adds its own rules for confidentiality terms about harassment and discrimination claims. Federal law also limits nondisclosure terms in some sexual harassment situations, and the National Labor Relations Board has challenged broad confidentiality and non-disparagement clauses for non-supervisory employees. Draft those clauses narrowly.
Where do restrictive covenants stand after the FTC fight?
In 2024, the Federal Trade Commission issued a rule that would have banned most noncompetes nationwide. A federal court in Texas set it aside before it took effect, and the FTC later dropped its defense of the rule. The agency still says it will pursue noncompetes it views as unfair on a case-by-case basis. So there’s no national ban, but there’s also no green light.
State law controls, and it’s moving. Illinois generally bans noncompetes for employees earning at or below a salary threshold, bans nonsolicitation agreements below a lower threshold, and requires that employees be advised to consult a lawyer and given at least 14 days to review. Colorado sharply limits noncompetes to highly compensated workers and requires separate notice. Missouri is more traditional and generally enforces reasonable restrictions that protect legitimate business interests, such as trade secrets and customer relationships, and its statute expressly allows employee nonsolicitation clauses of up to one year. Delaware, long a favorite choice of law, has seen its courts refuse to rewrite overbroad covenants.
At separation, check which agreements the employee actually signed, under which state’s law, and whether the restrictions are likely enforceable. A separation agreement is a good place to restate obligations, confirm the return of company property and data, and, if appropriate, narrow a covenant in exchange for a clean exit.
What should you do if a former employee files an agency charge?
Take it seriously and calendar the deadlines. Charges of discrimination generally must be filed with the EEOC within 180 days, or 300 days in states with their own fair employment agency, which includes Missouri and Illinois. Once you’re notified, you’ll usually be invited to submit a position statement and documents.
Before you write anything, issue a litigation hold to preserve emails, texts, personnel files and anything else related to the employee. Then build the position statement from the documents, not from memory. It should be accurate, consistent with what you told the employee and supported by records, because it can be used against you later. Don’t contact the former employee about the charge, and make sure no one does anything that looks like retaliation, such as a negative reference or contesting benefits without a good-faith basis.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to give a reason when I let someone go?
Generally, no, for at-will employees, though some states require written notice of separation or a service letter on request. Missouri, for example, has a service letter statute. Whatever reason you give, make sure it’s true and matches your records.
Can I make severance conditional on signing a release?
Yes. That’s the normal structure. Just don’t condition pay the employee has already earned, such as final wages or, in some states, accrued vacation, on signing the release.
Should I contest an unemployment claim?
Only when you have a good-faith basis, such as documented misconduct. Statements in unemployment proceedings can surface later in litigation, so keep them accurate and consistent.
Talk with Scott
A termination done well is quiet. A termination done poorly can follow you for years. If you’re planning a separation, drafting a severance agreement or responding to a charge, I’m glad to help. Reach me at slevine@aegislaw.com.
By Scott Levine, Founder and Managing Partner, AEGIS Law
Strategic Engagement
Consult with our Managing Partner.
Ready to review your enterprise risk or legacy strategy? Schedule a direct consultation with Scott Levine using the link below.




