An underpaid hail claim usually leaves you with four real options. You can supplement the claim with the carrier, invoke the appraisal provision in your policy, file suit for breach of the policy, or take the money and move on. Which of those fits depends almost entirely on why the number came back low. Carriers underpay for several different reasons, and the reason drives the remedy.

I have practiced for more than 35 years, and I spent nearly half of that career inside companies as a corporate officer and in-house counsel. That is where I learned that the cost of a dispute is never only the legal bill. It is also the hours you and your people spend on it instead of running the business. So this is a look at the options and at what each one really asks of you.

Why did my claim come back low?

Start with the loss breakdown that came with the payment, not with the check. Most property policies pay replacement cost in two stages. The first payment is actual cash value, which is the full repair cost less depreciation and less your deductible. The rest, the holdback, is released when the work is finished and you send in the invoice. Plenty of what looks like an underpaid hail claim is really a holdback that nobody explained.

The next possibility is scope. The carrier’s adjuster may have measured fewer squares than your roof has, priced a repair where the slope needs replacement, or left items out entirely. That is a different problem from pricing, where the quantities are right but the unit prices, the code upgrades or the general contractor’s overhead and profit are missing. Both of those live inside the estimate, and the estimate is a document you can audit. I take that apart separately, because it is where most of the money in these disputes sits.

The last reason is the serious one. The carrier may be saying the damage is not from the storm at all. Wear, age, foot traffic, poor installation, a manufacturing defect, or a weather event outside your policy period are all common positions. Read your declarations page and your endorsements too. Roof surfacing payment schedules and cosmetic damage exclusions are now common, especially on metal, and they change the math before anyone argues about scope.

What does supplementing an underpaid hail claim with the carrier involve?

This is the cheapest path and it resolves more claims than people expect. You put a written supplement request in front of the adjuster with specifics. Here is the line that is missing, here is the quantity, here is the photograph, here is the code provision or the manufacturer instruction that requires it. A written line-item estimate from a contractor who will actually sign the job at that number carries far more weight than a bid total on letterhead.

Ask for a reinspection and be there for it. Have your contractor on the roof at the same time as the adjuster. If the tear-off reveals a second layer, rotted decking or spaced sheathing, photograph it that day, before it gets covered. Those discoveries are legitimate supplements and they are nearly impossible to prove after the fact.

Do what the policy requires while all of this is going on. Carriers can ask for a sworn proof of loss, for documents, and in some cases for an examination under oath. Those are conditions, not suggestions, and a refusal hands the carrier a defense that has nothing to do with your roof. The deadlines attached to them vary by policy and by state, so read your own policy instead of relying on what someone told you about a different one.

Is appraisal a better option than suing?

Most property policies contain an appraisal provision. Either side can demand it when the disagreement is about the amount of the loss. Each party names an appraiser, the two appraisers choose an umpire, and an award signed by two of the three sets the number. There is no discovery, no deposition and no jury, and it is usually finished in a fraction of the time a lawsuit takes.

The limit is what appraisal can decide. It is built to resolve amount, not coverage. Whether appraisers can decide causation varies by state and by the wording of your policy, and that single question often decides whether appraisal is useful to you at all. If the carrier’s position is that the storm did not cause the damage, appraisal can leave you exactly where you started. I compare the two paths in detail in a separate article, because the choice deserves more than a paragraph.

What does suing your own insurer actually look like?

Suing on an underpaid hail claim starts with breach of the insurance contract. Many states also recognize some form of claim or penalty when a carrier refuses to pay without a reasonable basis, though the standard, the name and the proof required all differ. I am licensed in Missouri and Illinois, and they are not identical on this. Nobody should assume that what applies to a building in one state applies to the one across the river.

What litigation buys you is discovery and a jury. You get the claim file. You get to depose the adjuster who wrote the estimate, and often a corporate representative who has to answer for how the file was handled against the carrier’s own guidelines. You get to test the retained engineer’s causation opinion, move to exclude it if the methodology does not hold, and argue motions in limine before trial. None of that exists in appraisal.

What it costs is time and attention. These cases run on a scale of years, not months, with long quiet stretches where nothing visible happens and then short periods of real demand on you for documents, deposition dates and decisions. There are expert costs on your side as well. Any lawyer who tells you a property case is quick and painless is selling something.

How do I choose, and when is this fight not worth having?

Do the arithmetic before anything else. Take a real repair number from a contractor who will stand behind it. Subtract what the carrier has paid and what it still holds back. That gap is the only thing you are fighting over, and it has to be large enough to justify the path you pick. A modest gap usually belongs in a supplement rather than in a courtroom.

Then look at the clock. Property policies typically contain their own suit limitation provision, and it is often shorter than the general period for contract claims. Whether demanding appraisal stops that clock varies. Months of friendly negotiation have ended more claims than any carrier argument ever has, so find that provision in your policy early and calendar it.

Keep the building from getting worse in the meantime. Policies require you to protect the property from further damage, and a leak you let run undercuts your credibility along with your claim. Document before you tarp or repair. And be willing to hear that the fight is not worth having. I say that when it is true, because my years inside companies taught me that distraction has a price even when a case is winnable.

Frequently asked questions

Does cashing the first check mean I accepted the amount?

Usually not. On a replacement cost policy the first payment is normally actual cash value with depreciation held back, and depositing it is not a release. What matters is what you sign. Read anything labeled release, settlement agreement or full and final payment before it goes back, and ask about the language if it is not clear.

Can I handle this with a public adjuster instead of a lawyer?

Sometimes, and on a pure scope and pricing dispute a good public adjuster earns the fee. What a public adjuster cannot do is file suit, take a deposition, or preserve a claim against the carrier for the way it handled the file. Check the fee arrangement and the licensing rules in your state, and be careful with contracts that assign your policy benefits to a contractor.

How long do I have to sue my insurer?

Your policy almost certainly answers that, and the answer is often shorter than the ordinary limitation period for contracts. The length, when the clock starts, and whether a state will enforce a shortened period at all vary. Find that provision in your own policy early, because every day of negotiation runs against it.

Talk with Sheldon

First-party property disputes are the largest part of my practice. I represent commercial and residential owners against their own carriers, from the first supplement request through trial, and I will tell you before anything is filed what the path costs and what it will ask of you. If your claim came back short and you want a straight read on it, call me. Reach me at skorlin@aegislaw.com.

By Sheldon Korlin, Attorney, AEGIS Law

Attorney Advertising. This article is general information published by AEGIS Law for marketing purposes. It is not legal advice and should not be relied on as legal advice. It may not reflect current law, may not apply in your state or to your facts, and may contain errors or omissions. Laws change often and vary from state to state. Before acting on anything you read here, talk with a lawyer licensed in your jurisdiction who has reviewed your situation. Reading this article or contacting AEGIS Law does not create an attorney-client relationship, and you should not send confidential information until one exists. AEGIS Law lawyers are licensed in various states, and no lawyer is licensed in every state. Unless stated otherwise, no AEGIS Law lawyer is certified as a specialist by any state board or certifying organization. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Lawyer responsible for this content: Scott Levine, AEGIS Law, 601 S. Lindbergh Blvd., Frontenac, Missouri 63131, (314) 454-9100. The choice of a lawyer is an important decision and should not be based solely upon advertisements.

Select Categories

Strategic Engagement

Consult with our Managing Partner.

Ready to review your enterprise risk or legacy strategy? Schedule a direct consultation with Scott Levine using the link below.

Schedule an Appointment

BOOK NOW


Call Us

(314) 454-9100