A wage and hour investigation usually begins with one employee and one complaint, and it almost never stays that narrow. The investigator’s first move is a demand for payroll and time records, and what those records show determines nearly everything that follows. From there the inquiry tends to expand from the complaining employee to everyone paid the same way, from one location to all of them, and from the original issue to whatever else the records reveal.
Two things surprise owners. The first is that the investigation is not confined to the complaint that started it. The second is that intent carries very little weight. Liability for unpaid wages generally does not turn on whether you meant well or thought you were doing it right. I spent years inside companies watching payroll practices get set by habit rather than by anybody’s decision, and habit is exactly what these investigations are good at finding.
How does a wage and hour investigation start?
Most often with a complaint from a current or former employee. Sometimes with a directed investigation, where an agency selects an industry or a region for attention and works through employers in it. Sometimes with a referral from another agency that was looking at something else. Both federal and state labor agencies run these, the rules are not identical, and the two can proceed at the same time over the same payroll.
The identity of the complaining employee is generally not disclosed, and in many cases you never learn it. That matters enormously, because the instinct to figure out who complained is the single most expensive instinct in this entire process. Acting on a guess, even gently, creates a retaliation problem that is often easier for an employee to prove than the wage issue underneath it.
First contact is usually a letter or a call, followed by an opening conference and a written records request covering a defined period. The period requested is often longer than the complaint covers, and that is deliberate. It is also the first signal of how wide the inquiry intends to go.
What records will the investigator ask for, and what if ours are incomplete?
Expect requests for payroll registers, time records, an employee roster with job titles and contact information, pay rate histories, the handbook and any written pay policies, job descriptions, records of deductions, bonus and commission plans, and information about the company’s ownership and any related entities. Where classification is in question, the investigator will also want documents about what people actually do day to day rather than what their titles say.
If the records are incomplete, the practical burden lands on the employer. The obligation to keep accurate time and pay records sits with the company, and the required contents and retention periods vary by jurisdiction, so the applicable rule is the one to check rather than a rule of thumb. Where records are missing, investigators reconstruct hours from whatever else exists, including employee statements. Reconstruction rarely favors the employer, and arguing that the hours cannot be proven tends to help the other direction.
Produce accurately, completely and consistently, and have one person responsible for what goes out. Creating or adjusting records after a demand arrives turns a back wage dispute into a far more serious matter, and it is not recoverable. The questions about related companies and common ownership deserve particular care, because they often go to whether several entities get treated as one employer. Understand what is being asked before you answer it.
Who gets interviewed, and what can I say to my own employees?
Employees get interviewed, and non management employees are normally interviewed privately without a manager present. That is by design, and objecting to it accomplishes nothing. Managers and owners can be interviewed as well, and for those interviews you can generally have counsel involved. Investigators are also permitted to observe operations in many circumstances.
What you can control is your own side’s behavior, and this is where most of the damage in these matters gets done. Nobody should be discouraged from participating. Nobody should be asked afterward what they were asked or what they said. No schedules, assignments or hours should change for anyone connected to the inquiry while it is running. Retaliation exposure is separate from the wage exposure, it carries its own remedies, and it is frequently the easier case to prove.
Give supervisors written instructions on all of this before the interviews happen, because a well meaning foreman trying to defend the company is the most common source of a retaliation claim I see. You can tell employees truthfully that an investigation is underway, that cooperating is their choice, and that nothing about their job depends on it. A short neutral statement is safer than either silence or a speech.
Why does the scope of a wage and hour investigation keep widening?
Because a pay practice is almost never one employee’s problem. If a person was underpaid because of the way overtime is calculated, then everyone paid under that same calculation was underpaid too. Investigators look at the practice rather than the complaint, which is why the review moves from one person to a job classification, from one site to every site, and from a short period to a longer one.
The subject matter widens as well, because reviewing records for one issue surfaces others. Common additions include work performed off the clock before and after shifts, time rounding, automatic meal period deductions when the break was not actually taken, travel and preparation time, salaried employees treated as exempt whose actual duties do not support it, workers paid as independent contractors who function as employees, and piece rate or prevailing wage questions on public work. In construction and the trades, classification and prevailing wage are the two that come up most.
One technical point is worth its own paragraph because it accounts for so many findings. Overtime is generally computed on the regular rate of pay, and the regular rate includes more than base hourly wages. Non discretionary bonuses, shift differentials and certain other payments typically have to be folded in before the overtime multiplier is applied. A company that pays overtime faithfully on base rate alone can still owe money across its whole workforce, and it is usually the finding that surprises an owner most.
How does the investigation end, and what does it cost in management time?
With a closing conference and a statement of findings, typically including a back wage computation employee by employee and sometimes additional amounts the statute allows. From there the usual options are to agree to pay under the agency’s supervision, to dispute the computation and negotiate it, or to decline and let the agency or the employees pursue the claim in court. Which of those makes sense depends less on the total than on whether the dispute is about hours or about whether a practice was lawful at all. Those are two different projects.
Supervised payment is not a general release. What it resolves, which employees and which periods it covers, and whether a private suit can still follow varies, and employee by employee releases have limits. Read what is actually being signed. A resolution that leaves part of the workforce or part of the period open is not the clean ending it appears to be.
Expect future compliance to be part of the outcome. The agency’s real interest is in the practice changing, so plan on changing it and on documenting the change. That part is the only piece of this that pays for itself, because the same error running another year costs more than the computation you just settled.
The cost in management time is substantial and it falls on your most senior people. Someone has to assemble records, answer follow up questions, sit for an interview, keep supervisors from making things worse, and brief the owner. None of that work produces revenue. Budget for it honestly at the start, because treating a wage and hour investigation as a clerical task handled in spare moments is how a narrow inquiry becomes a wide one.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to let an investigator into my business?
The authority to enter and to demand records varies by agency and program, and there are established procedures, including subpoenas, for dealing with an employer who declines. Refusing as a reflex almost never improves the outcome and often widens the inquiry. It is a question worth getting advice on before you answer the first letter.
Can I talk to my employees about the investigation?
Yes, within limits. You can confirm that an investigation is happening and that participation is voluntary and will not affect anyone’s job. What you cannot do is question people about what they were asked, discourage cooperation, or keep track of who spoke with the investigator.
If I correct the problem now, will the investigation go away?
Generally no, though it helps. Fixing a practice going forward does not erase wages owed for past periods, and the agency will still compute what is due. It does affect how the company is viewed and it is the right move regardless, since the alternative is continuing to accrue the same liability.
Talk with Sheldon
I represent businesses in agency investigations and audits, including wage and hour matters, and I also do the employment and HR work that keeps a payroll practice from becoming one. My years as in house counsel left me fairly practical about the difference between a problem worth fighting and one worth fixing quickly and quietly. If an agency letter has arrived and you want to think through the response before you send it, I am glad to help. Reach me at skorlin@aegislaw.com.
By Sheldon Korlin, Attorney, AEGIS Law
Strategic Engagement
Consult with our Managing Partner.
Ready to review your enterprise risk or legacy strategy? Schedule a direct consultation with Scott Levine using the link below.




