The history of the billable hour is shorter than most lawyers think. For much of American history, lawyers charged fixed fees, many of them set by law or by bar fee schedules. Hourly billing grew out of the 20th century, as legal work got more complex and clients wanted to see what they were paying for. It didn’t become the norm until the late 1970s.
At its core, the traditional law firm model is simple. A client brings a legal problem, and a lawyer charges by the hour to solve it. Everyone knows that model. Fewer people know how it started, or why it stuck. I’ve led AEGIS Law for 20 years, and I think the history matters. It shows that the way lawyers charge has changed before, and that it’s changing again now. This piece is for business owners who pay legal bills and for lawyers who wonder whether the billable hour has to be permanent.

How were lawyers paid before the billable hour?
In the country’s early history, lawyers sold their services at fixed rates set by state law. Those rules allowed lawyers to collect annual retainers and bonuses. Still, the law regulated both the price of legal fees and who paid them. A lawyer didn’t decide what a case was worth. The legislature did.
That changed slowly. In 1908, the American Bar Association adopted its first Canons of Professional Ethics, which addressed the contingent fee. A contingency fee is paid only if the lawyer wins the case. Accepting it opened the door to other ways of paying for legal services. Over time, bar associations also published minimum fee schedules. Those schedules told lawyers the lowest price they could charge for common tasks, such as a title search or a simple will.
Fee schedules worked as a price floor. They protected lawyers’ incomes, but they also kept clients from shopping on price. That tension would matter later.
For most of the century, lawyers set fees by judgment. They looked at the value of the service and the result, and they wrote a number on the bill. Time was one factor, but it wasn’t the measure.
When did hourly billing begin?
The idea of tracking a lawyer’s time is older than the practice of billing for it. In 1914, Reginald Heber Smith, who ran a legal aid society, proposed recording lawyer time. His office didn’t charge fees. He wanted the records to run the office more efficiently.
Then the work itself got harder. In 1938, the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure took effect, and business regulation kept expanding. Those changes increased the amount of work it took to resolve a matter. As a result, it got harder for lawyers to set reasonable flat fees in advance. At the same time, clients grew wary of flat fees. Lawyers often failed to explain the link between the work they did and the fee they charged.
In 1958, the ABA published a pamphlet called “The 1958 Lawyer and His 1938 Dollar.” It worried that lawyers’ incomes had fallen behind those of doctors and dentists. Its answer was better timekeeping. The pamphlet called time the lawyer’s only expendable asset and suggested a target of 1,300 billable hours a year. The ABA then promoted timekeeping across the country for about a decade.
How did the history of the billable hour lead to today’s billing requirements?
Here’s the part that surprises people. Clients pushed for hourly billing. By the 1960s and 1970s, many clients wanted to see exactly what they were buying. Hourly bills gave them that. They also let lawyers get paid for the large amount of time they were spending on matters.
The courts helped clear the way. In 1975, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Goldfarb v. Virginia State Bar. The Court held that a bar-enforced minimum fee schedule violated federal antitrust law. With fee schedules gone, time became the common yardstick. By the late 1970s, hourly billing was the norm. Meanwhile, lawyers were consolidating into larger firms. Hours became the standard way to measure performance, and firms set annual billing requirements to protect profits.
Notice how far the target moved. The ABA once suggested 1,300 hours a year. Many firms now expect more. The billable hour started as a tool for clarity. Over time, it became a quota. For more on how pay systems shape lawyer behavior, read about why law firm compensation is still a black box.
Why does this history matter now?
The traditional law firm model has changed before, and it’s changing again. Many clients can’t budget for the high cost of the billable hour. In addition, traditional firms keep losing ground to more entrepreneurial firms. Those firms automate routine tasks, improve their processes, and cut both the time demands on lawyers and the money demands on clients.
AI is speeding that up. When software can draft a first version in minutes, billing for the hours it used to take gets hard to defend. I’ve written more about what AI means for the billable hour and the law firm business model. In short, the incentive to be slow is built into hourly billing. Clients see that more clearly every year.
The history of the billable hour also offers a lesson. Billing models last only as long as they serve clients. Fixed fees gave way when work got too complex to price in advance. Hourly billing won because clients wanted transparency. If clients now want speed and predictability more than a list of hours, the model will shift again. Lawyers who study the history of the billable hour can see that shift coming instead of being surprised by it.
At AEGIS Law, we’re one of those entrepreneurial firms. Our business model lets us hire experienced lawyers who focus on serving clients well, at lower rates than traditional firms. That doesn’t mean the hour disappears overnight. It means firms have to give clients a clear reason for every hour they bill. For more on how the old model falls short, read why the traditional law firm model is failing clients.
Frequently asked questions
Who invented the billable hour?
No single person did. Reginald Heber Smith proposed tracking lawyer time in 1914, and the ABA promoted timekeeping after its 1958 pamphlet. Clients and firms made hourly billing the standard by the late 1970s.
Why did minimum fee schedules end?
In Goldfarb v. Virginia State Bar in 1975, the Supreme Court held that a minimum fee schedule enforced by the bar violated federal antitrust law. After that, lawyers had to set their own prices.
What are the alternatives to hourly billing?
Common options include flat fees for defined work, contingency fees, monthly retainers, and hybrid arrangements. The right choice depends on how predictable the work is. Ask your lawyer which fits your matter.
Talk with Scott
If you’d like to talk about how your company pays for legal work, or about practicing at a firm that isn’t built around the billable hour quota, I’m glad to connect. Reach out to me here.
By Scott Levine
Strategic Engagement
Consult with our Managing Partner.
Ready to review your enterprise risk or legacy strategy? Schedule a direct consultation with Scott Levine using the link below.




