Choosing deal counsel comes down to one question: has this lawyer handled transactions like yours, often and recently? Complex deals, such as buying or selling a company, raising capital, or merging with a competitor, reward experience more than almost any other legal work. A lawyer who knows the usual terms and the usual traps negotiates faster, spots real risk sooner, and spends less of your money learning on the job.

Many owners hire the lawyer they already know for a deal. That lawyer may be excellent at leases, collections, or estate plans. However, a purchase agreement for a business is its own discipline. At AEGIS Law, we sit across the table from many different firms on business transactions. This guide explains why transaction experience matters, how to test for it, and what questions to ask before you sign an engagement letter.

Two professionals shaking hands across a table after choosing deal counsel for a complex transaction

Why does choosing deal counsel matter so much?

A business sale or acquisition packs a lot of risk into a few documents. The purchase agreement decides what you’re actually selling or buying. It also sets how price adjustments work, what each side promises about the business, and who pays if those promises turn out to be wrong. Small drafting choices in those sections can shift hundreds of thousands of dollars after closing. For example, the definition of working capital or the cap on indemnity often matters more than the headline price.

Experience also changes how the deal feels. A lawyer who has seen many letters of intent knows which points to fight on and which to concede. As a result, negotiations stay focused on the terms that move value. An inexperienced lawyer tends to do the opposite. They argue minor points, miss major ones, or redraft market-standard language that both sides would normally accept.

Industry knowledge matters too. A deal in health care, construction, or financial services can raise licensing, regulatory, or contract assignment issues that a general corporate lawyer may not expect. Choosing deal counsel who knows your industry, or who will bring in someone who does, helps avoid surprises late in the process. In addition, it keeps due diligence focused on the risks a buyer in your field will actually care about.

Finally, the right lawyer manages the process, not just the paper. Deals involve accountants, lenders, brokers, insurers, and sometimes regulators. Someone has to keep the closing checklist moving and make sure due diligence findings show up in the contract. That coordination is a skill built through repetition.

How does the other side’s lawyer affect your cost?

Here’s a point owners rarely hear. The experience of the lawyer on the other side affects your legal bill almost as much as your own lawyer’s experience does. When opposing counsel doesn’t know the usual terms, your lawyer spends time explaining them. Drafts go back and forth more often. Issues that should take one call take five. That’s one reason fee estimates for a transaction are hard to pin down at the start.

So it’s in everyone’s interest for both sides to have capable counsel. If you’re selling to a buyer with an inexperienced lawyer, or buying from a seller who plans to use a generalist, expect delays. In addition, expect your own fees to rise. It’s reasonable to encourage the other side, politely, to hire someone who does this work regularly. For a closer look at what drives transaction costs, see our guide to M&A legal fees.

A higher hourly rate doesn’t always mean a higher bill. An experienced deal lawyer may charge more per hour and still cost less overall. They know where to spend time and where not to. Therefore, compare likely total cost and quality of outcome, not just the rate sheet.

What should you ask when choosing deal counsel?

Start with volume and relevance. Ask how many transactions the lawyer has closed in the past two years, and how many were similar in size, structure, and industry to yours. Ask whether they usually represent buyers, sellers, or both. Then ask who will actually do the work. In many firms, a senior lawyer pitches the deal and a junior lawyer drafts it. That can be fine, but you should know the team and how it’s supervised.

Next, ask about process. How will they handle the letter of intent? Who coordinates due diligence? How do they work with your accountant and banker? A strong answer is specific. It should cover the steps from the letter of intent through closing, with a realistic timeline. Finally, ask how they bill. Common arrangements include hourly billing with an estimate, phased budgets, and capped or fixed fees for defined stages.

Be careful with labels. Missouri’s professional conduct rules let lawyers say which fields they practice in. However, under Rule 4-7.4, a lawyer generally can’t claim to be a “specialist” without a required disclaimer. So don’t rely on titles. Rely on track record, references, and how well the lawyer answers detailed questions about your deal.

What are the warning signs of the wrong lawyer?

Some signs show up early. The lawyer can’t explain common deal terms in plain English. They treat every provision in the other side’s draft as unacceptable. They haven’t asked about your goals after closing, such as staying on, getting paid quickly, or protecting employees. Each of those suggests they’re working from a general contract mindset, not a deal mindset.

Other signs show up mid-deal. Turnaround on drafts is slow and unpredictable. Issues from due diligence never make it into the purchase agreement. The lawyer seems surprised by standard requests, like escrow or holdback provisions, or by a quality of earnings review. Meanwhile, the deal timeline keeps slipping. If you notice these patterns, raise them right away. It’s easier to add experienced help in the middle of a deal than to fix a bad agreement after closing.

Also watch for the opposite problem. Some lawyers over-lawyer a modest deal, using terms built for large private equity transactions. Good deal counsel scales the process to the size and risk of the transaction. The goal is a deal that closes on terms you understand, at a cost that makes sense for what’s at stake.

Frequently asked questions

Can my regular business lawyer handle my company sale?

Sometimes. If they regularly handle business sales of your size, they may be a strong choice because they already know your company. If not, consider bringing in transaction counsel to lead the deal while your regular lawyer supports with history and records.

When should I hire deal counsel?

Before you sign a letter of intent. Many key terms, including price structure, exclusivity, and escrow, get set at the LOI stage. Once they’re agreed, they’re hard to reopen. Earlier is better if you’re preparing a company for sale.

Does the other side’s lawyer really affect my fees?

Yes. Inexperienced opposing counsel means more drafts, more calls, and more explaining. That time shows up on your bill. It’s fair to factor this in when you set a budget and timeline.

Talk with AEGIS Law

The right transaction lawyer helps you close on terms you understand, without wasted time. AEGIS Law represents buyers and sellers in business acquisitions, sales, and investments. Contact AEGIS Law to talk through your deal and how we would approach it.

By Robert Gold

Attorney Advertising. This article is general information published by AEGIS Law for marketing purposes. It is not legal advice and should not be relied on as legal advice. It may not reflect current law, may not apply in your state or to your facts, and may contain errors or omissions. Laws change often and vary from state to state. Before acting on anything you read here, talk with a lawyer licensed in your jurisdiction who has reviewed your situation. Reading this article or contacting AEGIS Law does not create an attorney-client relationship, and you should not send confidential information until one exists. AEGIS Law lawyers are licensed in various states, and no lawyer is licensed in every state. Unless stated otherwise, no AEGIS Law lawyer is certified as a specialist by any state board or certifying organization. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Lawyer responsible for this content: Scott Levine, AEGIS Law, 601 S. Lindbergh Blvd., Frontenac, Missouri 63131, (314) 454-9100. The choice of a lawyer is an important decision and should not be based solely upon advertisements.

Select Categories

Strategic Engagement

Consult with our Managing Partner.

Ready to review your enterprise risk or legacy strategy? Schedule a direct consultation with Scott Levine using the link below.

Schedule an Appointment

BOOK NOW


Call Us

(314) 454-9100